proper bagel is a modern, conceptual eatery with a laid-back, chic vibe. hailing from new york, our family brings with it over 40 years of experience in the art of traditional baking. inspired by our new city’s culinary creativity, we are committed to delivering old school flavors with a new school edge.

and for all you real bagel lovers, here’s the lowdown: our kettle-boiled bagels and bialys are mixed from scratch and baked in our stone-lined oven, daily.

amidst a minimal black-and-white interior, our vibrant showcases feature a curated selection of housemade salads, custom cream cheeses, and seasonal spreads. we proudly offer the finest selection of smoked fish flown in direct from brooklyn, n.y. and skillfully hand-sliced to order. so grab a dozen, and order by the pound to go.

wait time disclaimer

due to high volume and operating three different ordering methods / platforms (in-house, online, and delivery), there will always be wait times. these wait times vary from day to day, with friday through sunday being the busiest. if you are pressed for time, we strongly suggest checking or asking prior to ordering your food. we are incredibly efficient, but this is just simply something that is unavoidable.

click me for daily menu

click me for online ordering

click me for delivery / ubereats

click me to order a virtual gift card

got an event? let proper bagel take care of you with our extensive catering menu. from birthdays to morning office meetings, bridal brunches or midday studio sessions……we do it all! whatever bagel-based revelry you’re planning, sit back, relax, and let us create distinctive and unique platters to meet all of your hosting needs.

click me for catering menu

please email catering@properbagel.com for inquiries.